There’s something undeniably comforting about a home-cooked chicken dinner, but what if we told you that just a few pantry staples could take your usual baked chicken and make it unforgettable?
That’s exactly what this Blood Orange Cinnamon Chicken Thighs recipe does.
With warm cinnamon spice, bright citrus, and the subtle sweetness of our Blood Orange Cinnamon Jam, this dish is a bold yet balanced flavor bomb. It’s a go-to for cozy nights at home, impromptu dinner parties, or even a weeknight meal when you want something that feels fancy, but isn’t fussy.
The Magic Ingredient: Blood Orange Jam
Let’s talk about the jam that makes it all happen.
The Blood Orange Cinnamon Jam is one of those Kitchen Casual staples we fell in love with the moment we tasted it. The tart brightness of blood orange layered with the gentle spice of cinnamon creates a versatile condiment that’s equally at home on a cheese board or as the secret weapon in a savory glaze. In this recipe, it gets whisked into a marinade with olive oil, soy sauce, garlic, and fresh citrus juice — creating a rich, aromatic bath that turns humble chicken thighs into something truly craveable.
And yes, you’ll find this jam, along with a curated lineup of gourmet pantry goods, in our Kitchen Casual collection right here at Magnolias.
The Recipe: Blood Orange Cinnamon Chicken Thighs
👉 See full recipe card above
No changes needed, just follow it step-by-step, and let your oven do the rest.
How to Serve It
Pair it with:
-
Roasted potatoes or wild rice for a hearty meal
-
A fresh arugula salad tossed with fennel and citrus vinaigrette
-
A crisp white wine or blood orange spritz
This dish is especially lovely served straight from the baking dish, nestled among the softened orange slices and fennel. It’s rustic, fragrant, and full of flavor. Don’t skip the final broil for that perfectly crisped skin.
Make It a Kitchen Casual Moment
At Magnolias, we believe beautiful meals can be simple. That’s why we created the Kitchen Casual collection to give you the tools, flavors, and inspiration to entertain effortlessly.
Want to recreate this dish at home? Stop by or shop online for:
-
Lakonia Imports Olive Oil (ideal for high-quality olives and finishing drizzles)
-
Our hand-picked dipping bowls and trays for serving
-
Seasonal tea towels to style your space and clean up in style
You’ll also find pre-bundled gift sets that include jams, bread mixes, and kitchen linens, perfect for hostess gifts or a treat-yourself moment.
Final Thoughts
This Blood Orange Cinnamon Chicken is everything we love about Kitchen Casual:
A little sweet, a little savory, and just elevated enough to make everyday meals feel special.
Whether you’re cooking for two or a table full of friends, this is a recipe you’ll come back to again and again. And with the right ingredients already waiting in your pantry, you’re just a few simple steps away from a show-stopping meal.